Alicia Pérez-Porro
Marine biologist, responsible for policy interaction and institutional relations at the Centre for Ecological Research and Forestry Applications (CREAF) who has been to Antalya
It is certainly not good news that no agreement has been reached on a final text, not so much because of the omission of any reference to fossil fuels or a new financing target – which we already knew would be very difficult, if not impossible, but also because of the message it sends to the world that multilateralism is in decline and that it is difficult to reach a consensus to move forward at the pace required to implement the Paris Agreement and meet the most ambitious targets for tackling the climate emergency.
On the other hand, the most important aspect of this COP was not the final text. This is a sort of recent trend whereby all host countries want the name of the organising city or country to be enshrined in some agreement, such as the Paris Agreement; they want to go down in history, so to speak. But in reality, COPs do not necessarily have to produce these final texts; some do, but not all, and what really matters are the decisions on implementation.
This COP, which was very aptly dubbed the ‘COP of implementation’, was significant in that it broke the deadlock on those decisions that allowed us to continue making progress on the implementation of the Paris Agreement. In this regard, there are some decisions that have indeed been approved and adopted, such as the NAPs – the National Adaptation Plans, for example. But then there are other decisions that have been kicked down the road and passed on to COP32. That is where I see the greater risk and problem, rather than simply the fact that a final text has not been approved. This accumulation of decisions that have not been taken also implies a deadlock in this race towards the implementation of the Paris Agreement. This slows down the whole process, and we are not at a stage where we can afford to move any slower. On the contrary, we should be moving faster. Another thing demonstrated by this lack of final consensus at COP31 is the lack of ambition.
From here on, we have no choice but to continue working towards multilateralism and keep pushing forward; and those countries that do have the ambition – such as Spain, which is a country that does have that ambition right now – must continue to lead the way. We simply cannot afford to do otherwise. And looking to the future, we must also work at other levels: at sub-national level, at national level, and ensure that this negative outcome does not discourage us or lead to inaction. And by ‘people’, I mean governments.