Javier Baena Preysler
Professor of Prehistory at the Autonomous University of Madrid.
Is the study of good quality? Are the conclusions backed up by solid data?
‘Yes, it is a high-quality and rigorous study. We’re talking about one of the leading specialists in palaeogenetics, and one would expect nothing less from him and his team.’
How does this work fit in with the existing evidence?
"The medical aspects are a bit beyond me. In any case, and after a quick read, that 10 per cent potential incidence seems statistically insignificant to me. As for the palaeogenetic study, the problem is that we have a small sample of remains, and what’s more, they are not always well-preserved. In any event, it seems very sound.”
Have the authors taken confounding factors into account? Are there any significant limitations to bear in mind?
“The main drawback I see is the scope of the study. This type of research is somewhat reductionist in the sense that human behaviour cannot be reduced to a palaeoanthropological scale. Factors related to behaviour—and to a large extent genetic flow—are undoubtedly the result of our history (and this includes Neanderthals). On the other hand, archaeology can change our interpretation from one day to the next in the light of new findings. That’s the nature of our profession.”
What are the real-world implications?
“There are some ethical issues surrounding this topic that I haven’t fully grasped. From a medical perspective, I believe that the genetic analysis of our patients is sufficient to help us improve our health, regardless of who we owe certain traits to. Ultimately, we are the product of our biological and cultural evolution, and I do not believe that having inherited specific traits should be a reason to disown that history.”