Autor/es reacciones

Vicente Martínez Vizcaíno

Health and Social Research Centre Director, University of Castilla-La Mancha

Does the press release accurately reflect the study?

"Yes, on the whole the press release is a good reflection of the study’s data. It could be supplemented with some clarification regarding weaknesses acknowledged by the study itself, such as the fact that when it reports that 24.9 per cent of adolescents do not have a single ‘active’ day a week, this does not mean that they do not engage in any physical activity on any day, but rather that they do not reach 60 minutes of physical activity on any day of the week; thus, someone who, for example, 45 minutes a day would fall into this category. And this type of physical activity pattern is very common amongst those who go to the gym, which is very common amongst older people.”

Is the study of good quality? Are the conclusions supported by robust data?

“It would appear so; it is a high-quality study for describing national and global population patterns: 389 prevalence studies, most with national-level estimates, with data harmonised through a similar question in all studies and with statistical methods appropriate to the objectives and the data.

However, such precise estimates, with such narrow confidence intervals due to the large sample size, do not rule out the risk of selection bias—as these are school-based studies (not all adolescents attend school in every country)—nor endorsement bias, as self-reported physical activity is often overestimated.”

How does this study fit in with the existing evidence?

“This study updates the trend data that have been periodically collected through the Health Behaviour in School-aged Children (HBSC) and other surveys across a total of 195 countries. A similar publication from 2020 reported prevalence data showing that a similar proportion of adolescents (around 80 per cent) do not meet the recommendations of one hour of physical activity seven days a week, and that girls are less active than boys. Consequently, these figures mean we are still some way off meeting the target set by the WHO’s ‘More Active People for a Healthier World’ initiative, which aims for a 15 per cent reduction in the global prevalence of adolescents and adults who do not meet physical activity recommendations.

Incidentally, the Spanish data are in line with those reported in other Western countries, both in terms of overall estimates (21 per cent, 24 per cent, 20 per cent and 18 per cent of adolescents engaging in at least one hour of physical activity every day of the week in 2010, 2014, 2018 and 2022, respectively) and in terms of gender differences”.

Have the authors taken confounding factors into account? Are there any significant limitations that need to be considered?

“Confounding factors have been taken into account, yes, although only partially. Thus, the data have been stratified or adjusted for age, sex, country, region, year, population composition and variation at survey level. However, other additional factors such as variability in sampling design, the season, climatic conditions, gender norms, school provision, the use of digital media or rates of street crime have not been taken into account. And this last factor, together with gender norms, could be significant in explaining, at least in part, why women are less active.

The authors acknowledge that this study has significant limitations regarding the global representativeness of the data, as 55 countries are not represented, including India, home to 18 per cent of the world’s adolescent population; furthermore, there is a shortage of data from low-income countries. Secondly, most of the data came from school-based surveys, and school-attending adolescents may differ from the general population in places where school attendance is low; furthermore, in countries where school drop-out occurs at an earlier age, age patterns may reflect selection bias rather than actual age patterns, so the results on age patterns should be interpreted with caution. Finally, due to data limitations regarding the failure to quantify total weekly light-to-moderate physical activity, it was not possible to estimate the proportion of adolescents meeting the 2020 WHO physical activity guidelines, which include recommendations on the average number of minutes of activity per week (as opposed to active days per week), vigorous-intensity activity and muscle-strengthening activities.”

What are the real-world implications?

"The study argues that priority should be given to promoting physical activity among adolescent girls and those who are least physically active. Its data help to distinguish between those populations requiring general improvements in access and those needing support to maintain activity levels. However, it does not assess whether safer streets, school programmes, sports facilities or gender-sensitive activities will lead to specific improvements.

As recommendations for future studies, it is necessary to include under-represented countries and out-of-school adolescents, and to use quantitative measures of total weekly physical activity, so that estimates are in line with the WHO’s 2020 recommendations.

Furthermore, more specific and context-specific approaches are required, prioritising those who are least active, alongside measures targeting the entire population to address the social, cultural and environmental barriers that prevent participation, particularly among girls. Without these conditions, global targets for adolescents’ physical activity will continue to go unmet.”

EN